Best Car Insurance Companies of September 2026
Top-rated carriers side by side, scored on coverage, price, claims and financial strength. Comparing is free and takes about two minutes.
1
5.0★★★★★
Our rating
State Farm® Auto Insurance
With the State Farm Personal Price Plan, You Can Save an Average of $740 on Car Insurance.
Get a Free Quote and See How Much You Can Save with State Farm.
Create an Affordable Price Just for You. Fast, Free Quotes are Available Online.
Get quote
at statefarm.com for your rate
2
4.8★★★★★
Our rating
PolicyProviders.com Auto Insurance
One form, 20+ carriers compared
Matches your profile against 20+ carriers, including GEICO, Progressive and Allstate
Always free to use, with no obligation to buy
Share a few details about you and your vehicle and review the matches side by side
Get quote
at policyproviders.com
3
4.7★★★★★
Our rating
Farmers® Auto Insurance
More than 20 discounts, and they stack
Signal rewards safe driving with up to 30% off, starting at 5% just for enrolling
Bundle auto with home, or add a second vehicle, for a multi-policy discount
Credits for defensive driving, autopay, loyalty, and hybrid or electric vehicles
Get quote
at farmers.com
4
4.6★★★★★
Our rating
SelectMyPolicy Auto Insurance
Licensed agents in all 50 states
Start with your ZIP code and one simple form
Quotes come from licensed agents authorized to write in your state
Independent service — not owned by any of the carriers it quotes
Get quote
at selectmypolicy.com
5
QuoteCompareNow
4.5★★★★★
Our rating
QuoteCompareNow.com
Same coverage, priced side by side
See what participating insurers charge for the coverage you already carry
ZIP code, vehicle and a few basics — about two minutes, no phone call to start
Keep your current policy if nothing on the list beats it
Get quote
at quotecomparenow.com
Our methodology
How we evaluate auto insurers
Coverage and limits
Which coverages are offered, the optional endorsements available, and how high limits can be set.
Price and discounts
Quoted premium at identical coverage, plus the discounts that actually reduce it.
Claims and service
How quickly and fairly claims are paid, measured against published complaint indexes.
Financial strength
The insurer’s ability to pay claims, based on AM Best and comparable ratings.
Compare rates in about 2 minutes
Free · Licensed agents only